Canonical Classics ← 第一回
第一回
靈líng根gēn育yù孕yùn源yuán流liú出chū
心xīn性xìng修xiū持chí大dà道dào生shēng

A Numinous Root, Conceived and Nurtured, Brings Forth Its Source · The Cultivation of Mind and Nature Gives Birth to the Great Way

仙石孕猴
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

仙石孕猴 The Immortal Stone Conceives a Monkey

那nà座zuò山shān正zhèng當dāng頂dǐng上shàng,有yǒu一yí塊kuài仙xiān石shí。其qí石shí有yǒu三sān丈zhàng六liù尺chǐ五wǔ寸cùn高gāo,有yǒu二èr丈zhàng四sì尺chǐ圍wéi圓yuán。三sān丈zhàng六liù尺chǐ五wǔ寸cùn高gāo,按àn周zhōu天tiān三sān百bǎi六liù十shí五wǔ度dù;二èr丈zhàng四sì尺chǐ圍wéi圓yuán,按àn政zhèng曆lì二èr十shí四sì氣qì。上shàng有yǒu九jiǔ竅qiào八bā孔kǒng,按àn九jiǔ宮gōng八bā卦guà。四sì面miàn更gèng無wú樹shù木mù遮zhē陰yīn,左zuǒ右yòu倒dào有yǒu芝zhī蘭lán相xiāng襯chèn。蓋gài自zì開kāi闢pì以yǐ來lái,每měi受shòu天tiān真zhēn地dì秀xiù,日rì精jīng月yuè華huá,感gǎn之zhī既jì久jiǔ,遂suì有yǒu靈líng通tōng之zhī意yì。內nèi育yù仙xiān胞bāo,一yí日rì迸bèng裂liè,產chǎn一yì石shí卵luǎn,似sì圓yuán毬qiú樣yàng大dà。因yīn見jiàn風fēng,化huà作zuò一yí個gè石shí猴hóu,五wǔ官guān俱jù備bèi,四sì肢zhī皆jiē全quán。便biàn就jiù學xué爬pá學xué走zǒu,拜bài了le四sì方fāng。目mù運yùn兩liǎng道dào金jīn光guāng,射shè沖chōng斗dǒu府fǔ。驚jīng動dòng高gāo天tiān上shàng聖shèng大dà慈cí仁rén者zhě玉yù皇huáng大dà天tiān尊zūn玄xuán穹qióng高gāo上shàng帝dì,駕jià座zuò金jīn闕què雲yún宮gōng靈líng霄xiāo寶bǎo殿diàn,聚jù集jí仙xiān卿qīng,見jiàn有yǒu金jīn光guāng燄yàn燄yàn,即jí命mìng千qiān里lǐ眼yǎn、順shùn風fēng耳ěr開kāi南nán天tiān門mén觀guān看kàn。二èr將jiàng果guǒ奉fèng旨zhǐ出chū門mén外wài,看kàn的de真zhēn,聽tīng的de明míng。須xū臾yú回huí報bào道dào:「臣chén奉fèng旨zhǐ觀guān聽tīng金jīn光guāng之zhī處chù,乃nǎi東dōng勝shèng神shén洲zhōu海hǎi東dōng傲ào來lái小xiǎo國guó之zhī界jiè,有yǒu一yí座zuò花huā果guǒ山shān,山shān上shàng有yǒu一yì仙xiān石shí,石shí產chǎn一yì卵luǎn,見jiàn風fēng化huà一yì石shí猴hóu,在zài那nà裡lǐ拜bài四sì方fāng,眼yǎn運yùn金jīn光guāng,射shè沖chōng斗dǒu府fǔ。如rú今jīn服fú餌ěr水shuǐ食shí,金jīn光guāng將jiāng潛qián息xī矣yǐ。」玉yù帝dì垂chuí賜cì恩ēn慈cí曰yuē:「下xià方fāng之zhī物wù,乃nǎi天tiān地dì精jīng華huá所suǒ生shēng,不bù足zú為wéi異yì。」那nà座zuò山shān正zhèng当dāng顶dǐng上shàng,有yǒu一yí块kuài仙xiān石shí。其qí石shí有yǒu三sān丈zhàng六liù尺chǐ五wǔ寸cùn高gāo,有yǒu二èr丈zhàng四sì尺chǐ围wéi圆yuán。三sān丈zhàng六liù尺chǐ五wǔ寸cùn高gāo,按àn周zhōu天tiān三sān百bǎi六liù十shí五wǔ度dù;二èr丈zhàng四sì尺chǐ围wéi圆yuán,按àn政zhèng历lì二èr十shí四sì气qì。上shàng有yǒu九jiǔ窍qiào八bā孔kǒng,按àn九jiǔ宫gōng八bā卦guà。四sì面miàn更gèng无wú树shù木mù遮zhē阴yīn,左zuǒ右yòu倒dào有yǒu芝zhī兰lán相xiāng衬chèn。盖gài自zì开kāi辟pì以yǐ来lái,每měi受shòu天tiān真zhēn地dì秀xiù,日rì精jīng月yuè华huá,感gǎn之zhī既jì久jiǔ,遂suì有yǒu灵líng通tōng之zhī意yì。内nèi育yù仙xiān胞bāo,一yí日rì迸bèng裂liè,产chǎn一yì石shí卵luǎn,似sì圆yuán毬qiú样yàng大dà。因yīn见jiàn风fēng,化huà作zuò一yí个gè石shí猴hóu,五wǔ官guān俱jù备bèi,四sì肢zhī皆jiē全quán。便biàn就jiù学xué爬pá学xué走zǒu,拜bài了le四sì方fāng。目mù运yùn两liǎng道dào金jīn光guāng,射shè冲chōng斗dǒu府fǔ。惊jīng动dòng高gāo天tiān上shàng圣shèng大dà慈cí仁rén者zhě玉yù皇huáng大dà天tiān尊zūn玄xuán穹qióng高gāo上shàng帝dì,驾jià座zuò金jīn阙què云yún宫gōng灵líng霄xiāo宝bǎo殿diàn,聚jù集jí仙xiān卿qīng,见jiàn有yǒu金jīn光guāng燄yàn燄yàn,即jí命mìng千qiān里lǐ眼yǎn、顺shùn风fēng耳ěr开kāi南nán天tiān门mén观guān看kàn。二èr将jiàng果guǒ奉fèng旨zhǐ出chū门mén外wài,看kàn的de真zhēn,听tīng的de明míng。须xū臾yú回huí报bào道dào:「臣chén奉fèng旨zhǐ观guān听tīng金jīn光guāng之zhī处chù,乃nǎi东dōng胜shèng神shén洲zhōu海hǎi东dōng傲ào来lái小xiǎo国guó之zhī界jiè,有yǒu一yí座zuò花huā果guǒ山shān,山shān上shàng有yǒu一yì仙xiān石shí,石shí产chǎn一yì卵luǎn,见jiàn风fēng化huà一yì石shí猴hóu,在zài那nà里lǐ拜bài四sì方fāng,眼yǎn运yùn金jīn光guāng,射shè冲chōng斗dǒu府fǔ。如rú今jīn服fú饵ěr水shuǐ食shí,金jīn光guāng将jiāng潜qián息xī矣yǐ。」玉yù帝dì垂chuí赐cì恩ēn慈cí曰yuē:「下xià方fāng之zhī物wù,乃nǎi天tiān地dì精jīng华huá所suǒ生shēng,不bù足zú为wéi异yì。」


逐句解 Line by line

那nà座zuò山shān正zhèng當dāng頂dǐng上shàng,有yǒu一yí塊kuài仙xiān石shí。 那nà座zuò山shān正zhèng当dāng顶dǐng上shàng,有yǒu一yí块kuài仙xiān石shí。

On the very summit of that mountain there lay an immortal stone.

We have arrived. A 仙石 is not a "magic rock" in the fairy-tale sense: 仙 means the Daoist immortals, so this is stone steeped in their power, the kind of thing that has been quietly gathering force for an age. 正當 takes 當 in its first tone, dāng, "right at, directly on top of," not dàng.

其qí石shí有yǒu三sān丈zhàng六liù尺chǐ五wǔ寸cùn高gāo,有yǒu二èr丈zhàng四sì尺chǐ圍wéi圓yuán。 其qí石shí有yǒu三sān丈zhàng六liù尺chǐ五wǔ寸cùn高gāo,有yǒu二èr丈zhàng四sì尺chǐ围wéi圆yuán。

The stone was three zhàng, six chǐ, and five cùn in height, and two zhàng, four chǐ in girth.

The units are 丈 (zhàng, ten 尺), 尺 (chǐ, roughly a foot) and 寸 (cùn, roughly an inch), so the stone stands 36.5 尺 tall and measures 24 尺 round — 圍圓 is its girth. Odd numbers to pick. The very next line explains why they are not odd at all.

三sān丈zhàng六liù尺chǐ五wǔ寸cùn高gāo,按àn周zhōu天tiān三sān百bǎi六liù十shí五wǔ度dù;二èr丈zhàng四sì尺chǐ圍wéi圓yuán,按àn政zhèng曆lì二èr十shí四sì氣qì。 三sān丈zhàng六liù尺chǐ五wǔ寸cùn高gāo,按àn周zhōu天tiān三sān百bǎi六liù十shí五wǔ度dù;二èr丈zhàng四sì尺chǐ围wéi圆yuán,按àn政zhèng历lì二èr十shí四sì气qì。

Its height of three zhàng six chǐ five cùn answered to the three hundred sixty-five degrees of the celestial circuit; its girth of two zhàng four chǐ answered to the twenty-four solar terms of the regulating calendar.

按 (àn) means "matches, is modelled on." So: 36.5 for the 周天三百六十五度, the 365 degrees of the sky's yearly round, and 24 for the 二十四氣, the twenty-four solar terms that divide the farming year (政曆 is the official calendar that fixes them). The stone is not merely large. It is built to the specification of the year.

上shàng有yǒu九jiǔ竅qiào八bā孔kǒng,按àn九jiǔ宮gōng八bā卦guà。 上shàng有yǒu九jiǔ窍qiào八bā孔kǒng,按àn九jiǔ宫gōng八bā卦guà。

On it were nine apertures and eight holes, answering to the Nine Palaces and the Eight Trigrams.

The count goes on. 九竅, the "nine openings" of a living body, answer to the 九宮 — the Nine Palaces of the magic square (洛書), where every row, column and diagonal adds up to fifteen. The 八孔 answer to the 八卦, the eight trigrams of the Yijing. Number by number the stone is being assembled as a small working model of everything: the sky, the seasons, and the pattern of change itself.

四sì面miàn更gèng無wú樹shù木mù遮zhē陰yīn,左zuǒ右yòu倒dào有yǒu芝zhī蘭lán相xiāng襯chèn。 四sì面miàn更gèng无wú树shù木mù遮zhē阴yīn,左zuǒ右yòu倒dào有yǒu芝zhī兰lán相xiāng衬chèn。

On none of its four sides was there any tree to cast shade; yet to left and right, instead, numinous fungus and orchids set it off.

The line turns on a contrast, so the two small grammar words carry the weight: 更 reads gèng ("not even"), and 倒 reads dào ("on the contrary"), not dǎo. 芝蘭 are the lucky 靈芝 fungus and the orchid, both emblems of purity, and 相襯 (with 相 in its first-tone "mutually" sense) means they set the stone off. A bare, unshaded rock with nothing but holy plants beside it: the power here is undiluted.

蓋gài自zì開kāi闢pì以yǐ來lái,每měi受shòu天tiān真zhēn地dì秀xiù,日rì精jīng月yuè華huá,感gǎn之zhī既jì久jiǔ,遂suì有yǒu靈líng通tōng之zhī意yì。 盖gài自zì开kāi辟pì以yǐ来lái,每měi受shòu天tiān真zhēn地dì秀xiù,日rì精jīng月yuè华huá,感gǎn之zhī既jì久jiǔ,遂suì有yǒu灵líng通tōng之zhī意yì。

For ever since the first parting of Heaven and Earth it had drunk in the truth of Heaven and the fairness of Earth, the essence of the sun and the brilliance of the moon; and having been so wrought upon for so long, it came at last to possess a spiritual awareness.

This is the sentence the whole novel grows out of. Ever since the world was split open, the stone has been drinking in four influences — 天真 and 地秀, the true breath of Heaven and the fine breath of Earth, then 日精 and 月華, the essence of the sun and the flowering of the moon (華 here huá). Keep that up long enough and you get 靈通: awareness dawning. Rock becomes mind. Everything after this is consequence.

內nèi育yù仙xiān胞bāo,一yí日rì迸bèng裂liè,產chǎn一yì石shí卵luǎn,似sì圓yuán毬qiú樣yàng大dà。 内nèi育yù仙xiān胞bāo,一yí日rì迸bèng裂liè,产chǎn一yì石shí卵luǎn,似sì圆yuán毬qiú样yàng大dà。

Within it an immortal womb was nurtured, which one day burst apart and brought forth a stone egg, round and about the size of a ball.

仙胞 is an immortal womb or birth-sac, the 世德堂本 and 維基文庫 reading; some editions have 仙胎 (xiān tāi), "immortal embryo," which comes to the same thing. We follow Wikisource. 迸裂 reads bèng liè, "to burst apart" — 迸 is bèng, never bìng. 毬 is just an older way of writing 球, a ball.

因yīn見jiàn風fēng,化huà作zuò一yí個gè石shí猴hóu,五wǔ官guān俱jù備bèi,四sì肢zhī皆jiē全quán。 因yīn见jiàn风fēng,化huà作zuò一yí个gè石shí猴hóu,五wǔ官guān俱jù备bèi,四sì肢zhī皆jiē全quán。

Meeting the wind, it changed into a stone monkey, its five senses all present and its four limbs complete.

Wind touches the egg and it becomes a monkey: 五官俱備,四肢皆全, all five senses in place and all four limbs whole, complete from the first instant. But look at what he does not have. He is only 石猴, "the stone monkey." He earns 美猴王 by winning a cave, and receives 孫悟空 from a teacher much later still. The namelessness is not an oversight — it is the starting condition of a self that has not been made yet.

便biàn就jiù學xué爬pá學xué走zǒu,拜bài了le四sì方fāng。 便biàn就jiù学xué爬pá学xué走zǒu,拜bài了le四sì方fāng。

At once it learned to crawl and to walk, and made its bows to the four quarters.

便就 (biàn jiù) is "at once"; read 便 as biàn, not pián, and 了 as the neutral-tone le. The newborn's first act is a bow to the four directions — nobody taught him. Before he can speak he is already lining himself up with the cosmos, which is a fair summary of his whole career.

目mù運yùn兩liǎng道dào金jīn光guāng,射shè沖chōng斗dǒu府fǔ。 目mù运yùn两liǎng道dào金jīn光guāng,射shè冲chōng斗dǒu府fǔ。

From its eyes there shot two shafts of golden light, striking upward to the Palace of the Dipper.

斗府 is the palace of the 北斗, the Northern Dipper, and so stands for the whole civil service of Heaven; read 斗 as dǒu (the Dipper, or a dry measure), never dòu ("to fight," properly 鬥). 射沖 is to shoot up and pierce. A newborn monkey whose stare reaches the throne of Heaven: the book is telling you at once how large he is and how much trouble is on the way.

驚jīng動dòng高gāo天tiān上shàng聖shèng大dà慈cí仁rén者zhě玉yù皇huáng大dà天tiān尊zūn玄xuán穹qióng高gāo上shàng帝dì, 惊jīng动dòng高gāo天tiān上shàng圣shèng大dà慈cí仁rén者zhě玉yù皇huáng大dà天tiān尊zūn玄xuán穹qióng高gāo上shàng帝dì,

This startled that Most Sacred One of High Heaven, the Greatly Compassionate and Benevolent, the Jade Sovereign and Great Celestial Worthy, August High Lord of the Mysterious Vault of Heaven,

The full ceremonial style of the 玉皇大帝, the Jade Emperor, laid out title by title — 高天上聖 "Most Holy of High Heaven," 大慈仁者 "the Greatly Merciful and Kind," 玉皇大天尊 "Jade Sovereign and Great Celestial Worthy," 玄穹高上帝 "August High Lord of the Dark Vault" (穹 qióng, the dome of the sky; 尊 zūn). Notice how much of it there is. Wú spends the whole novel letting Heaven's pomp deflate itself, and this is the first instalment.

駕jià座zuò金jīn闕què雲yún宮gōng靈líng霄xiāo寶bǎo殿diàn,聚jù集jí仙xiān卿qīng, 驾jià座zuò金jīn阙què云yún宫gōng灵líng霄xiāo宝bǎo殿diàn,聚jù集jí仙xiān卿qīng,

who, enthroned in the Treasure Hall of the Numinous Empyrean within the Cloud Palace of the Golden Portal, had gathered his immortal ministers about him.

駕座 ("enthroned in state") is the 維基文庫 / 世德堂本 reading; many modern editions print the near-twin 駕坐 ("seated"), both jià zuò. 金闕 is the golden gate-tower of the palace and 靈霄寶殿 the Treasure Hall of the Numinous Empyrean (霄 xiāo, the high sky), often written 凌霄寶殿 elsewhere. 仙卿 (xiān qīng) are his immortal ministers. Heaven is run as a court, morning audience and all.

見jiàn有yǒu金jīn光guāng燄yàn燄yàn,即jí命mìng千qiān里lǐ眼yǎn、順shùn風fēng耳ěr開kāi南nán天tiān門mén觀guān看kàn。 见jiàn有yǒu金jīn光guāng燄yàn燄yàn,即jí命mìng千qiān里lǐ眼yǎn、顺shùn风fēng耳ěr开kāi南nán天tiān门mén观guān看kàn。

Seeing the golden light blazing up, he straightway commanded Thousand-Mile Eye and Wind-Following Ear to open the Southern Gate of Heaven and observe.

燄 is the 世德堂本 / Wikisource form of the now-standard 焰, flame. 千里眼 ("Thousand-Li Eye") and 順風耳 ("Ear that Follows the Wind") are Heaven's surveillance department — stock figures of popular religion, later attached to the 媽祖 cult, who between them can see and hear anything anywhere. 南天門, the Southern Gate of Heaven, is the border post between the celestial world and ours.

二èr將jiàng果guǒ奉fèng旨zhǐ出chū門mén外wài,看kàn的de真zhēn,聽tīng的de明míng。 二èr将jiàng果guǒ奉fèng旨zhǐ出chū门mén外wài,看kàn的de真zhēn,听tīng的de明míng。

The two officers duly went forth beyond the gate at his command; they saw the matter truly and heard it plainly.

One character, two jobs, a few clauses apart. Here 將 is jiàng, "officer"; a moment later, in 金光將潛息, the same character is jiāng, "about to." Note also the colloquial spelling: 看的真,聽的明 uses 的 where standard writing has 得 (de) — "saw it clearly, heard it plainly." And 果 (guǒ) here means "duly, sure enough" — not its usual "fruit" or "result."

須xū臾yú回huí報bào道dào: 须xū臾yú回huí报bào道dào:

In a little while they returned and made their report, saying:

須臾 (xū yú) is the fixed phrase for "in a moment." In 回報道, 道 is the verb dào, "to say," which opens the speech that follows.

「臣chén奉fèng旨zhǐ觀guān聽tīng金jīn光guāng之zhī處chù,乃nǎi東dōng勝shèng神shén洲zhōu海hǎi東dōng傲ào來lái小xiǎo國guó之zhī界jiè, 「臣chén奉fèng旨zhǐ观guān听tīng金jīn光guāng之zhī处chù,乃nǎi东dōng胜shèng神shén洲zhōu海hǎi东dōng傲ào来lái小xiǎo国guó之zhī界jiè,

'Your servants, obeying the decree, observed and listened at the place of the golden light. It lies within the bounds of the little kingdom of Aolai, east of the sea, in the Eastern Continent of Superior Spirit.

臣, "your servant," is the self-lowering pronoun anyone uses in front of a superior. 之處 takes 處 as the noun chù, "place," not the verb chǔ. The address is the one built up in the opening passages: 東勝神洲 (Pūrvavideha, easternmost of the four Buddhist continents around Mount Sumeru), and then 傲來, the invented kingdom on its eastern sea.

有yǒu一yí座zuò花huā果guǒ山shān,山shān上shàng有yǒu一yì仙xiān石shí,石shí產chǎn一yì卵luǎn, 有yǒu一yí座zuò花huā果guǒ山shān,山shān上shàng有yǒu一yì仙xiān石shí,石shí产chǎn一yì卵luǎn,

There is a Mountain of Flowers and Fruit, and upon the mountain an immortal stone, and the stone gave birth to an egg.

The officers re-tell the birth we have just watched, in almost the same words. That is not clumsiness. Vernacular novels grew out of professional storytelling, where a striking event was worth hearing twice — narrator's version, then a character's — and the repetition swells the moment instead of padding it. Expect this doubling throughout the book. 花果山 is named here for the audience's benefit.

見jiàn風fēng化huà一yì石shí猴hóu,在zài那nà裡lǐ拜bài四sì方fāng,眼yǎn運yùn金jīn光guāng,射shè沖chōng斗dǒu府fǔ。 见jiàn风fēng化huà一yì石shí猴hóu,在zài那nà里lǐ拜bài四sì方fāng,眼yǎn运yùn金jīn光guāng,射shè冲chōng斗dǒu府fǔ。

Meeting the wind it became a stone monkey, which there bows to the four quarters; from its eyes wheels a golden light that shoots up to the Palace of the Dipper.

Phrase for phrase the report mirrors the narration: 拜四方, 眼運金光,射沖斗府. Readings as before, 斗 dǒu and 沖 chōng. 那裡 here is "there" (nà lǐ), written 裡 in the Wikisource text where some editions have 里.

如rú今jīn服fú餌ěr水shuǐ食shí,金jīn光guāng將jiāng潛qián息xī矣yǐ。」 如rú今jīn服fú饵ěr水shuǐ食shí,金jīn光guāng将jiāng潜qián息xī矣yǐ。」

Now that it takes food and drinks water, the golden light is about to die away.'

服餌 (fú ěr) is to take something in; in Daoist writing it usually means swallowing elixirs, but here it is plain eating and drinking. 將 is now jiāng, "about to," and 潛息 is to sink away and stop. There is a neat logic in it: the moment the stone-born creature starts on ordinary food, his supernatural light dims. Feed a marvel and it turns into an animal. 矣 (yǐ) marks the change as good as done.

玉yù帝dì垂chuí賜cì恩ēn慈cí曰yuē:「下xià方fāng之zhī物wù,乃nǎi天tiān地dì精jīng華huá所suǒ生shēng,不bù足zú為wéi異yì。」 玉yù帝dì垂chuí赐cì恩ēn慈cí曰yuē:「下xià方fāng之zhī物wù,乃nǎi天tiān地dì精jīng华huá所suǒ生shēng,不bù足zú为wéi异yì。」

The Jade Emperor, graciously bestowing his kindness, declared: 'A thing of the world below, born of the very essence of Heaven and Earth — it is nothing to wonder at.'

垂賜恩慈 — handing kindness graciously down from above (垂 chuí, 賜 cì). 不足為異 takes 為 as wéi: "not enough to count as strange." Keep this line in mind. The god who shrugs at a stone giving birth will spend the next several chapters failing to control what it produced, and the novel never once lets the celestial bureaucracy look clever.


總評 Commentary

This is where the funnel finally reaches its point. Having laid out the shape of the cosmos and the geography of four continents, Wú Chéng'ēn (吳承恩) narrows to one stone on one summit and produces his hero out of it. The chain of cause runs unbroken from the 365 degrees of the turning sky down to a creature small enough to crawl: cosmic measurements, a long soaking in the essence of Heaven and Earth, an egg, a monkey, a beam of light, and Heaven's reply.

The stone's measurements are not decoration. Its height of 三丈六尺五寸 matches the 365 degrees of the 周天; its girth of 二丈四尺 matches the 二十四氣 of the calendar; its nine openings and eight holes match the 九宮 and the 八卦 of the Yijing (易經). The monkey is therefore a working model of the universe, his body keyed to year, season and the pattern of change — the same style of thinking that runs Shào Yōng's (邵雍) Huangji jingshi (《皇極經世》), quoted a few pages earlier. Build your hero out of the whole cosmic order and you have announced, without preaching, that this is no beast-fable. Anthony C. Yu reads this nameless stone creature as the first form of the 心猿, the mind-monkey whose training is the book's spiritual argument.

Two things repay attention. First, he has no name. He is 石猴, the stone monkey, and nothing more; 美猴王 and 孫悟空 are both chapters away, and the gap between being born and being named is part of the allegory of a self not yet formed. Second, the scene ends on a joke that keeps paying out for the rest of the book. The monkey's stare reaches the Jade Emperor's throne — and the Jade Emperor, in full court, with one officer who sees a thousand li and another who hears the wind, pronounces the prodigy 不足為異, "nothing to wonder at." Andrew H. Plaks notes how steadily the novel punctures the dignity of Heaven's administration. The god who shrugs here will soon be unable to contain what this stone has made.